The NALC and Bonhoeffer


The newsletter from the new North American Lutheran Church reporting on its recent convocation here in Ohio appeared in my mailbox this morning. I subscribe because it is important to know the full breadth of any conversation.

Reading the lengthy reports, I was once again chilled by the negativity that runs like an angry torrent through everything the NALC writes about itself. This denomination is not for something as against something - specifically, the 2009 vote of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America to open the ministry of the church to gay and lesbian pastors and other professional workers living in committed relationships. This single issue constitutes the rock upon which the NALC is attempting to build its church (see Sunday's Gospel reading, Matthew 16:13-20).

The conversation the NALC has been having since its official founding a year ago is that the ELCA is wrong on this issue - not just wrong, but dead wrong. Can one ever hope to have a genuine Christian conversation in the midst of such blanket condemnations -- the same kind that dominate the rhetoric of Tea Party activists?

“If anyone thinks theology doesn’t matter, we should remember that we would not be here without the theological failure of the ELCA,” prominent theologian Carl Braaten said at the NALC convocation. “Bad theology, like poisonous food, always makes the body sick and that also goes for Christ’s Body, the Church.”

Even more disturbing are the parallels the NALC's new bishop, John Bradosky, drew on the one hand between the ELCA and the Nazi-submissive German Evangelical Church of the 1930s, and the NALC and Dietrich Bonhoeffer's activism, on the other.

"Dietrich Bonhoeffer was one of the leaders of the Confessing Church movement that opposed and separated itself from the German church because it was conscripted by the culture and political agendas, willing to compromise the truth for the sake of its own survival, willing to offer cheap grace while turning a blind eye to a culture that opposed the truth of the Gospel," Bradosky said. "Bonhoeffer wrote, 'When Christ calls a person, He bids him come and die.' Bonhoeffer gave his life for the sake of boldly confessing Jesus Christ. The need for the confessing church has never been greater. The NALC is rooted in the confessing movement."

These comparisons are outrageous. Should the ELCA dignify such rhetoric with a response? If not, what is the consequence of its continued silence?

Postscript: In terms of tone, compare the NALC proceedings to that of the 2011 ELCA Churchwide Assembly, "Freed in Christ to Serve," wrapping up today. Which better reflects the life and ministry of Jesus?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

LET CREATION SING

Image
(From Sunday, March 11, 2018) Sometimes I go outside and try to feel how the breezes are blowing not around but through my body. I am a porous thing of the wind, miraculously held in place by skin -- or, as quantum physics might tell us, -- a holistic entanglement of immaterial energy waves, as are all material things. This dissolves the superior view of human-hood over against creation, of which I find myself frequently guilty, and place me in solidarity with all that is around me, animate and inanimate. The experience of being in solidarity with God's creation is a form of prayer. Listen, and you can hear all creation singing. Everywhere there is life, there is song. The Bible tell us that the entire breadth of creation shares equally with human being in actively praising God. "Let the sea roar, and all that fills it” we sing in Psalm 96, "let the field exult, and everything in it" (vv. Ilb-12a; RSV). In Psalm 98, “Let the floods clap th
Read more

The heart of worship

Image
Yesterday we reflected on works righteousness as if affects philanthropic giving. The statistics seem to suggest that large donors give generally not out of genuine concern for the needs of humanity, in particular the poor, but in order to be noticed. We give to see our names on a building, or to be placed in the top 10 list of donors to our university, or to make a lasting impact on the life of some nonprofit institution for which we will be remembered. (James 2:15-16: "If a brother or sister is naked and lacks daily food, and one of you says to them, 'Go in peace; keep warm and eat your fill,' and yet you do not supply their bodily needs, what is the good of that?") This same attitude dominates the life of our congregations, at the expense of what we need most -- the growing awareness within each of us of the light of Christ which burns at the center of our being. In many parishes activity is perceived to be the main sign of life. (We have given up on growt
Read more

Feed My Sheep

Image
Trinity Lutheran Seminary in Bexley, Ohio, which last year merged with Capital University across the street, has a new dean who is widely admired. In a recent edition of her weekly newsletter, Dean Kathryn Kleinhans talked about the state of seminary education across the ELCA: “The numbers are out. This year the seminaries of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America – together – are graduating a total of 114 students available for call. That’s not even two for each of the ELCA’s 65 synods. Geographical restrictions limit even further the number of candidates available for a call anywhere in the church. Any of our bishops will tell you that the need is much greater than that!" Why are there so few seminary graduates? It's complicated, but the bottom line is that the ELCA itself is struggling. Congregations are closing or merging (and members are always lost in mergers), few are flourishing, and those who are somewhere in between are cutting
Read more